So I had this thought this morning about the lottery and taxes. Both are systems governments use to raise money from the people to pay for things that benefit the people.
One system — a tax — is mandatory.
The other — a lottery — is not.
Anti-tax sentiment is all the rage these days, a symptom, in my opinion, that the concept of collective civic responsibility has eroded to a shameful degree in this country. The GOP and so-called moderate Democrats oppose meaningful tax reform that would make our tax system fairer and more sustainable, choosing instead to protect the rich as if trickle down economics hadn’t proved itself a failure by now. Additionally, people making anti-tax arguments typically ignore the inconvenient fact that they, themselves, benefit from vital tax-funded programs such as public schools, police departments, fire departments, departments of transportation, etc.
So, taxes are mandatory and the lottery is not, and you’d think that, given this erosion in civic responsibility, Americans would choose not to buy lottery tickets, knowing the money goes to the government in order to fund government programs.
Let’s check this hypothesis by looking at some numbers, using my home state of Washington as a sample:
2010 Washington State Tax and Lottery Revenues
| Tax | |
| Lottery | $491,000,000 |
So much for that idea.
Now, the knee-jerk response to this data is that the obvious difference between the two systems is that people who pay taxes, by doing so, don’t have a chance to win multi-million dollar prizes.
But that reasoning brings us right back to the whole civic responsibility thing. Sure, “there’s something in it for me” when it comes to the lottery, but really it’s “there might be something in it for me”, whereas “there’s always something in it for me” where taxes are concerned…
…just not things like a new house, new car, new home theater system, world travel, etc.
* Update: Ok, so, eating crow is never a pleasant thing, and I’m currently choking on an embarrassingly large portion. I kinda thought that the $15+ million figure was ridiculously low, and I even went looking on the interwebs for corroborating information, but I couldn’t find anything.
Since I use a pseudonym here, a Facebook friend was kind enough to point out my mistake by posting the comment “he left out the last three zeros”, as if “he” wasn’t me. It was a sweet, thoughtful gesture that I appreciate very much, and yet it should be clear that I was sloppy, which is inexcusable. I can’t stand it when others play free and loose with the facts, either out of ignorance or maliciousness, and so I have to hold myself to the same standard.


When I 
So, the 